Private Label Surrogacy
Menu
Choosing an agency

How do you choose a surrogacy agency?

The short answer

Choose a surrogacy agency on nine verifiable criteria, in this order: who holds the money (independent licensed escrow, not the agency); who reads the surrogate's medical records (a doctor, not a coordinator); whether the surrogate's psychological evaluation and attorney are independent; the agency's published ethics standard; the people involved in matching and your day-to-day contact; current wait time to match, defined; success rates, defined per transfer and per journey; itemized pricing with written refund and rematch terms; and references from current parents and surrogates. Private Label Surrogacy, founded in 2017 by Nancy Block, RN, a former Co-President of SEEDS, publishes its position on all nine. Size and marketing budget are not on the list.

Portrait of Nancy Block, RN, founder and director of Private Label Surrogacy

Written by Nancy Block, RN

Founder and Director. Fertility nurse, 17 years at Northwestern Memorial Hospital. Former Co-President of SEEDS.

Last updated

Three women talking at a consultation table

Why do the nine criteria come before price or size?

Because price and size do not tell you whether your money is safe, whether your surrogate was screened properly, or who will answer the phone at 2 a.m. The nine criteria do.

Price matters, and you should compare it. But the agency fee is one line in a budget where most journeys land between $150,000 and $210,000 with clinic fees and insurance, and clinic charges vary widely from clinic to clinic. The surrogate's compensation, third-party costs, insurance and your clinic's fees make up most of it, and those apply at any agency. Choosing on the agency fee alone is choosing on the smallest variable.

Size is even less useful. A large agency can hold client money in its own account. Any agency, large or independent, can use independent escrow and a doctor's review. PLS does not hold funds for surrogate expenses or surrogate compensation. An independent licensed escrow company does.

The nine criteria below are in order of consequence. The first three protect you from the outcomes that are hardest to undo: lost money, a surrogate who was not medically ready, and professionals who answer to the agency instead of to you. The rest describe how the agency works day to day and what it tells you about its results.

How to use the list: send the same nine questions to three to five agencies by email before your first calls. Ask for written answers. On each call, ask follow-up questions about the answers you received, and note which agencies answered specifically and which answered in general terms. Score each criterion as strong, partial or missing. The agency with the most "strong" scores on criteria 1 to 3 should stay on your list even if its fee is higher.

Every criterion is verifiable. For each one, the question is not "does the agency say it does this?" but "can I see it?" Ask for written answers, compare three to five agencies on the same list, and check what you can yourself.

Private Label Surrogacy was founded in 2017 by Nancy Block, RN, who has worked in egg donation and surrogacy since 2000. Our answers to all nine appear at the end of this page. Judge us on the same terms as everyone else.

Criterion 1: who holds the money?

This is the first question because it is the one with the most at stake. Intended parents deposit the surrogate's compensation and expenses months before most of it is paid. Whoever holds that money holds your journey's financial safety.

What a strong answer looks like: an independent licensed escrow agent, with no ownership or staff link to the agency, holding funds in a segregated account in the parties' names. Statements come directly from the escrow company. You can choose a different escrow company if you want. The agency has no authority to move funds.

What to be careful of: escrow held in house, an escrow company that shares an owner or address with the agency, statements forwarded by the agency, and reluctance to name the bank.

How to verify: look up the escrow company's license on the state regulator's site, ask for a sample statement before you deposit, and confirm the account name and bank with the escrow company directly.

PLS: Escrow generally opens after medical clearance. Costs that come before that are invoiced to the intended parents directly, not through escrow. PLS refers you to independent attorneys, escrow companies, insurance agencies (including surrogate-friendly policies) and fertility clinics when you need them. You choose which providers to use. PLS has never held client funds. Read more on the escrow page.

Criterion 2: who reviews the surrogate's medical records?

A surrogate candidate's prenatal and delivery records show how her previous pregnancies went: complications, the type of delivery, anything that might affect a new pregnancy. Someone has to read them closely and decide whether the clinic should see her.

What a strong answer looks like: a doctor reviews each candidate's available medical records before her profile is shown to intended parents, and summarizes them for your fertility clinic. The clinic still does its own medical screening; the doctor's review means the clinic sees a candidate who has already been read carefully.

What to be careful of: records "reviewed" by a coordinator without medical training, or forwarded to the clinic unread. That shifts the screening onto the clinic and can mean months lost when a candidate fails clinic screening after you have matched.

How to verify: ask who reads the records, what that person's credentials are, and who receives the written summary.

PLS: Mark Silverberg, DDS, MD, reviews the surrogate's available medical records, summarizes them and flags inconsistencies before she is presented to you. All available records go to your fertility clinic. His summary is confidential: only PLS and your clinic receive it. Read more about doctor's record review.

Criterion 3: are the psychologist and attorneys independent?

The surrogate's psychological evaluation, her legal representation and yours each protect someone. They can only do that if the professional answers to that person, not to the agency.

What a strong answer looks like: the psychological evaluation is done by an independent licensed professional, not an agency employee. Each side has its own attorney who practices reproductive law in the relevant state. You pay for both attorneys, and the surrogate's attorney answers only to her.

What to be careful of: an in-house psychologist evaluating candidates the agency needs to place, one attorney for both sides, or an agency that requires you to use its lawyer.

How to verify: ask whether the psychologist and attorneys are employees, contractors or independent, and whether you can choose your own attorney.

PLS: PLS does not employ in-house psychologists, attorneys or escrow staff. It refers to independent licensed professionals on purpose, as a conflict-of-interest policy. You may choose your own attorney.

Criterion 4: what ethics standard does the agency publish?

An ethics standard is only useful if it is written down and you can hold the agency to it. Ask to see it.

If an agency does not publish a standard, it is worth asking why, and what guidance it follows instead.

What a strong answer looks like: a written standard covering screening, money, surrogate treatment and how results are reported, that you can read and check.

How to verify: read the standard, and ask how the agency follows it.

PLS: Nancy Block, RN, is a former Co-President of SEEDS. PLS follows ASRM guidance. PLS publishes its own standard, the PLS Standard: nurse-led medical care, a published ethical standard, independent escrow, surrogates treated as partners, and results in the open. Ask any agency you are considering for the same: the written standard, and where you can check it.

Criterion 5: who is involved in matching, and who is your day-to-day contact?

Matching is the most consequential decision the agency makes for you. Ask who is involved. Then ask who will manage your journey day to day.

What a strong answer looks like: a named, experienced person is involved in every match and oversees it, and a named case manager manages the day-to-day journey. You know their names before you sign.

What to be careful of: matching by an algorithm or a rotating intake team, and an agency that will not tell you who your case manager is.

How to verify: ask for the names of the people involved, how you will reach them, and what happens after hours.

PLS: Nancy is involved in every match and oversees it. Your case manager manages the day-to-day journey. PLS case managers Natalie Gaudio-Fricano and Jenni Symons are both former surrogates: Natalie delivered a boy for an international couple in 2016 after a first-transfer success, and Jenni delivered in 2019 and 2021. Jan Telman Berman, Global Surrogacy Coordinator, manages national and international cycles, and your case manager is reachable after hours when needed. This is not a line staffed 24 hours a day; in an emergency call 911, and for a mental health crisis call or text 988.

How surrogates are treated affects your journey directly. Ask what support the surrogate receives beyond compensation. At PLS, surrogates receive mental-health support, and PLS recommends a $750,000 term life policy for each journey. A surrogate who is supported well is easier to work with, more likely to raise a concern early, and more likely to stay in close contact with you.

Criterion 6 and 7: wait times and success rates, defined

Both numbers are easy to quote and easy to make look good. The definition is what tells you whether they mean anything.

Wait time. Ask when the clock starts and stops. A useful definition is the time from signing the agency agreement to meeting a surrogate who has already passed screening. Some agencies count from when profiles are first shown, or match with a candidate who has not yet been screened and may fail clearance later. A short quoted wait with an unscreened surrogate can turn into a long one.

Success rate. Ask what the denominator is. There are three different numbers. Live birth rate per embryo transfer is a clinical number, driven mainly by embryo quality. Live birth rate per journey is the share of matched parents who bring a baby home, including rematches and repeated transfers. Match rate is the share of signed parents who are matched, and says nothing about births. A single blended percentage hides which one you are being shown.

What a strong answer looks like: a defined wait time, dated, with the start and end points stated; results reported with their definitions.

PLS: On average, intended parents are matched about nine months after signing. It depends on the clinic's criteria and on what you are looking for in a surrogate. Matching timelines vary with the fertility clinic's criteria and with what intended parents and surrogates are looking for. The whole journey typically takes 18 to 24 months. Most journeys run closer to 24 months from start through delivery. PLS reports results as counts with definitions: more than 100 journeys and more than 60 babies born since 2017. We are building a yearly report on journeys started, matches completed and births, each with its definition. Clinical outcomes are decided by independent physicians and clinics, so we report them only where we can track them reliably. PLS does not publish a blended percentage. Nancy's own career includes more than 4,000 matches since she founded her first agency in 2000. See wait times defined and success rates defined.

Criterion 8: pricing, refund and rematch terms in writing

What a strong answer looks like: an itemized budget that separates the agency fee, third-party costs, the surrogate's compensation package, insurance and clinic costs. A fee schedule staged to milestones. Refund and rematch terms written into the contract, fee by fee.

What to be careful of: one bundled price with no breakdown, pressure to pay everything up front, discounts for paying early, and refund terms described as "case by case."

How to verify: ask for the agreement before you sign and read the refund and rematch clauses. Ask what happens to each fee if the match ends, the transfer fails or you withdraw.

PLS:

Item PLS figure
Program fee $47,500*, paid in three installments
Program fee installments First payment when you sign the agreement, $22,500*; second payment at matching, $20,000*; third payment at medical clearance by the fertility center, $5,000*
Platinum Plan $62,500*, with unlimited rematches and no second agency fee if the first surrogate cannot proceed (she withdraws, does not pass clinic screening, or the match ends before a live birth); clinic and surrogate costs still apply, so it is not a fixed price. The Platinum Plan does not limit surrogate compensation.
Item Typical amount
Third-party costs $15,300 to $29,000 (legal, escrow, psychological evaluation, background checks, insurance review, travel, monitoring)
Surrogate health insurance, if needed $5,000 to $40,000
Surrogate compensation, first-time base $60,000*, up from $55,000
IVF and clinic fees Paid directly to your clinic
Typical total journey Most journeys $150,000 to $210,000 with clinic fees and insurance; clinic charges vary widely

These costs are estimates and may vary. Only PLS program fees are fixed.

Compare the agency fee across agencies only after you have lined up the rest of the budget. Two agencies with the same fee can lead to very different totals if one bundles third-party costs and the other itemizes them.

Criterion 9: references and surrogate reviews

Ask to speak with a recent intended parent and a surrogate who has delivered with the agency. Ask them about communication, payments, and how problems were handled, not just how the story ended.

Online reviews describe experiences. They do not show screening rigor or financial controls. Read them alongside the other eight criteria, not instead of them. Pay attention to what surrogates say: late payments and unanswered calls usually show up on the surrogate's side first.

What a strong answer looks like: the agency connects you with both a parent and a surrogate, without scripting the conversation.

PLS: After a consultation, we can introduce you to a current or past PLS parent who has agreed to speak with you. PLS's case managers are themselves former surrogates, and PLS stands behind surrogates when things go wrong elsewhere: it has taken on three pro bono cases from another agency.

How does PLS answer each criterion?

Criterion What to ask What a strong answer is PLS answer
1. Who holds the money "Who holds client funds, and can I see their license?" Independent licensed escrow in the parties' names Independent licensed escrow, opened after medical clearance; you choose your escrow company
2. Medical record review "Who reads the surrogate's records?" A doctor, with a written summary to your clinic Mark Silverberg, DDS, MD, reviews the surrogate's available medical records and summarizes them; his summary is confidential, for PLS and your clinic only
3. Independent professionals "Are the psychologist and attorneys independent?" Yes, separate counsel for each side Yes; PLS employs no psychologists, attorneys or escrow staff
4. Ethics standard "What standard do you publish?" A written standard you can check The PLS Standard; PLS follows ASRM guidance; Nancy Block is a former Co-President of SEEDS
5. Matching and day-to-day contact "Who is involved in matching, and who is my day-to-day contact?" Named people you can reach Nancy is involved in every match and oversees it; your case manager manages the day-to-day journey; both case managers are former surrogates
6. Wait time "From when to when?" Defined, dated, screened surrogate at match On average, matched about nine months after signing
7. Success rate "What is the denominator?" Defined metrics, not a blend A yearly report on journeys started, matches completed and births is in progress; no blended percentage
8. Pricing and terms "Can I see an itemized budget and the refund clause?" Itemized, staged, written Itemized budget; $47,500* fee staged in three payments
9. References "May I speak with a parent and a surrogate?" Yes, unscripted Yes, after a consultation: a current or past PLS parent who has agreed to speak with you

If you would like to walk through the nine with Nancy, book a consultation. Bring the same nine to every agency call, including ours.

Sources

  • SART, Society for Assisted Reproductive Technology, for how per-transfer success rates are defined and reported.

  • Private Label Surrogacy fee schedule, agency agreement and escrow policy.

Questions people ask

Frequently asked questions

What is the most important thing when choosing a surrogacy agency?

Who controls your money. Independent licensed escrow separates your funds from the agency's survival.

Is a bigger surrogacy agency safer?

No. The agency failures of 2024 to 2026 included large operations; safety comes from escrow structure, screening and independent professionals, not size.

How many agencies should I compare?

Three to five, scored on the same nine criteria with written answers.

What should I look for in an agency's ethics standard?

A written standard covering screening, money, surrogate treatment and how results are reported, that you can read and check. PLS follows ASRM guidance.

Who are the PLS case managers?

Your case manager manages the day-to-day journey. PLS case managers Natalie Gaudio-Fricano and Jenni Symons are both former surrogates.

* Excludes third-party fees, including but not limited to medical fees.

* Suggested amounts. They are not guaranteed and they are not a maximum set by PLS.

Read next