What criteria are collected from intended parents and surrogates?
Matching starts with the same set of questions, asked of both sides. You answer them in the Intended Parent Questionnaire after you sign. Each surrogate answers them during her application and interview. At Private Label Surrogacy (PLS), the two sets of answers are compared before anyone is introduced.
Her criteria carry the same weight as yours. A surrogate is choosing a family as much as you are choosing a surrogate, and a match only works when both lists are met. Answering these questions carefully is the most useful work you do before you meet anyone.
The criteria fall into three groups.
The decisions that cannot change later
- Number of embryos to transfer. PLS journeys transfer one embryo.
- Termination. Under what circumstances, if any, you would request that a pregnancy be ended, and whether she would agree.
- Vaccination. Which vaccines she will or will not receive during pregnancy.
The relationship
- Communication style and frequency. Weekly texts, a call after every appointment, or something in between.
- Attendance. Whether you want to attend appointments, the transfer and the birth, and whether she wants you there.
- The relationship after birth. Annual updates, occasional visits, or a close ongoing friendship.
- Openness. Her openness to LGBTQ+ parents, single parents and international parents.
Logistics
- The surrogate's state. PLS recruits in surrogacy-friendly states. Some parents want a surrogate in one state or near their clinic.
- Embryo status. Whether your embryos are created, and whether they are PGT-A tested. Some surrogates prefer tested embryos.
- Timing. When you want to start, and when she is available.
| Criterion | Why it is asked | Typical answers | Deal-breaker or flexible |
|---|---|---|---|
| Number of embryos to transfer | Written into the agreement | PLS journeys transfer one embryo | Deal-breaker |
| Termination | A surrogate cannot be compelled; views must align in advance | Only for a threat to her life; for a serious fetal anomaly; not at all | Deal-breaker |
| Vaccination | Affects her care and is written into the agreement | Will take recommended pregnancy vaccines; prefers not to | Deal-breaker for many parents |
| Communication frequency | Sets expectations for nine months | Weekly, after appointments, monthly | Flexible within a range |
| Attendance at appointments and birth | Affects her privacy and your travel | All, key scans only, the birth only | Flexible within a range |
| Relationship after birth | Sets expectations for years | Annual update, occasional visits, close contact | Flexible within a range |
| Openness to LGBTQ+, single or international parents | Some surrogates have a preference | Open to all; specific preferences | Deal-breaker where it applies |
| Surrogate's state | Law, travel and delivery hospital | Any surrogacy-friendly state; one state | Usually flexible |
| Embryo status | Readiness and transfer success | Tested embryos ready; embryos in progress | Usually flexible |
For what surrogates weigh when they read a family's profile, see what surrogates look for in intended parents.
Which criteria are deal-breakers, and which are flexible?
The deal-breakers are the decisions that affect her body and your child, and that cannot be negotiated once a pregnancy is underway: transfer number, termination and, for many parents, vaccination. If your answers and hers differ on any of these, you are not matched. That is a PLS rule, not a preference.
Here is why. A surrogate cannot be legally compelled to undergo any procedure. A contract clause on termination sets expectations and financial consequences; it does not give either side control over the other. The only reliable protection is to match two parties who already agree. See termination clauses.
The flexible criteria are the ones that can meet in the middle: how often you talk, how many appointments you attend, what contact looks like after birth. These still matter. Unspoken expectations about communication cause real strain over nine months. But a surrogate who prefers monthly updates and parents who hope for weekly ones can usually agree on something in between, and write it down.
Logistics are usually the most flexible of all. Widening your state preference is often the simplest way to shorten matching.
How to prepare your own answers before you sign:
- Talk with your partner first. Couples sometimes discover they disagree on termination or transfer number only when the questionnaire asks. Settle it between you before it reaches a surrogate.
- Ask your clinic about transfer number. Your reproductive endocrinologist can tell you what the clinic recommends for your embryos.
- Know your embryos. How many you have and whether they are tested shape both your answers and which surrogates will be interested.
- Be honest about contact. If you want a close relationship, say so. If you want a respectful, lighter one, say that. Either is a good match for the right surrogate.
What is screened before a profile is shown?
Every surrogate completes screening before her profile reaches you. Before pre-introduction and matching: application and interview, medical record review, background check, insurance review, psychological evaluation, and medical clearance by the surrogate's physician or OB. In more detail:
- Application, confirming the PLS criteria: age 21 to 43, US citizen or permanent resident, a BMI within her clinic's limit (BMI limits are set by each clinic), at least one healthy full-term pregnancy and currently parenting, non-smoker, financially stable and not relying on government assistance, stable home.
- Interview with the PLS team about her reasons for carrying, her family and support, and her answers to the matching criteria.
- Medical record review by Mark Silverberg, DDS, MD. Dr. Silverberg reviews the surrogate's available medical records, summarizes them and flags inconsistencies before she is presented to you. All available records go to your fertility clinic. His summary is confidential: only PLS and your clinic receive it.
- Background check.
- Insurance review of her health plan for surrogacy exclusions.
- Psychological evaluation by an independent licensed professional, not a PLS employee.
- Medical clearance by the surrogate's physician or OB.
After the match, your fertility clinic does its own medical screening, following ASRM guidance for gestational carriers.
Screening comes first so that you are less likely to grow attached to a profile that cannot proceed. It is also part of why matching takes time.
What is in a surrogate profile, and what is in yours?
A surrogate profile tells you who she is and how she answered the matching criteria. It typically covers:
- Her family: her partner, if she has one, and her children.
- Where she lives, and her support system for appointments and recovery.
- Her pregnancy history, in plain terms, with Dr. Silverberg's medical summary going to your clinic.
- Why she wants to carry for another family.
- Her answers on transfer number, termination and vaccination.
- How she would like to communicate, and what she hopes for after the birth.
Your profile does the same for her. It tells her about you, your family, how you came to surrogacy, your embryos, and your answers to the same questions. Write it for her. She is deciding whether to spend the next year and a half working with you.
How to read a surrogate profile:
- Start with the deal-breakers. Check her answers on transfer number, termination and vaccination against yours. PLS has already done this, but read them in her words.
- Then her support system. Who drives her to appointments, who looks after her children during the transfer trip and after delivery, and how her partner feels about the journey.
- Then the relationship. How she wants to communicate and what she hopes for after the birth. Ask yourself whether you could keep that rhythm for nine months.
- Last, logistics. Her state, her distance from your clinic, her timing.
What to put in your own profile: who you are, how you came to surrogacy, what your embryos are, and your answers in plain language. Photos of your family and your home help. Avoid a sales pitch; she wants to know you, not be persuaded.
Profiles are presented one at a time, selected against your criteria, each with her photos, a letter from her, her history and her preferences. Profiles are not browsed from a database. PLS shares profiles only after you sign, so screened surrogates are introduced only to committed parents.
How does the video match meeting work?
When you and the surrogate have both read each other's profiles and both want to proceed, PLS arranges a video meeting. Her partner often joins. Your PLS case manager is present to keep the conversation on the decisions that matter.
The meeting is a conversation, not an interview. You talk about families, previous pregnancies, how you each picture the next year, and the hard decisions in your own words. You do not discuss compensation or contract terms; those belong to the attorneys after the match is confirmed.
The meeting typically runs about an hour. Afterward, each side has time to think and talk it over at home before confirming.
For what to ask and what she is likely to ask you, see the video match meeting.
What makes a match official?
A match is official when both sides confirm in writing, separately, to PLS after the meeting. Neither side confirms in front of the other. That gives each of you room to decide without pressure. Each side sends its written confirmation within 48 hours of the meeting. The match is formed when both confirmations are in.
Once both confirmations are in:
- The second payment at matching is due. It is $20,000* of the $47,500* program fee.
- Escrow generally opens after medical clearance. Costs that come before that are invoiced to the intended parents directly, not through escrow. PLS never holds client money. PLS refers you to independent attorneys, escrow companies, insurance agencies (including surrogate-friendly policies) and fertility clinics when you need them. You choose which providers to use.
- Each side retains its own independent attorney to draft the gestational carrier agreement.
- Your clinic schedules its own medical screening of her.
The legal phase (agreements signed) usually takes four to six weeks from here.
From this point your case manager is your day-to-day contact. You can reach Nancy and Mark whenever you need them. PLS case managers Natalie Gaudio-Fricano and Jenni Symons have both been gestational surrogates themselves. They keep the communication rhythm you agreed on, track appointments and reimbursements, and are the first call for either side when something comes up.
Why does PLS match on values before logistics?
Because logistics can be solved and values cannot.
A surrogate in a different state means more travel. A surrogate who prefers fewer calls means agreeing on a rhythm. Those are problems with answers. A surrogate who would not terminate a pregnancy for a serious anomaly, matched with parents who would ask her to, is a problem with no good answer. It surfaces at the worst moment of a pregnancy, and the contract cannot resolve it.
Nancy Block has been involved in matching families since she founded The Center for Egg Options Illinois in 2000, and has made more than 4,000 matches since 2000. She is a former Co-President of SEEDS. Matching on values first is the practice that experience produces. Rapport matters. But rapport is not the test.
Values-first matching also protects the surrogate. She is a partner in the journey, with her own family and her own views. Matching her with parents who share her answers means she is less likely to have to choose between her conscience and her contract. That is part of the PLS Standard: the ethical and medical standard every journey is held to. Agreement on the decisions that cannot be compromised later is.
What happens if either side says no?
Either side can say no at any point before the match is official, without penalty. You can decline a profile. She can decline yours. Either of you can decline after the video meeting. PLS continues matching.
A no is information. When a profile is declined, the reason helps sharpen the next search. Sometimes it shows a criterion that matters more than you realized. Sometimes it shows one that matters less.
On average, intended parents are matched about nine months after signing. It depends on the clinic's criteria and on what you are looking for in a surrogate. Matching timelines vary with the fertility clinic's criteria and with what intended parents and surrogates are looking for. If matching is taking longer than you planned, three things help most: widening your state preference, finishing your embryos, and revisiting any flexible criterion you have treated as fixed. PLS can tell you which of your criteria are narrowing the search.
The Platinum Plan, at $62,500*, adds unlimited rematches and no second agency fee if the first surrogate cannot proceed (she withdraws, does not pass clinic screening, or the match ends before a live birth). Clinic and surrogate costs still apply, so it is not a fixed price. The Platinum Plan does not limit surrogate compensation.
For how PLS reports these numbers and how to compare agencies, see surrogacy agency wait times.
Sources
- ASRM (American Society for Reproductive Medicine), guidance on gestational carriers. https://www.asrm.org