Private Label Surrogacy
Menu
LGBTQ+ and single parents

How does surrogacy work for two dads, step by step?

The short answer

Surrogacy for two dads has six steps: 1) sign with an agency and arrange independent escrow; 2) select an egg donor and complete sperm testing and FDA-required infectious disease screening; 3) create embryos by IVF, with chromosome testing (PGT-A) if you and your doctor choose it; 4) match with a screened gestational surrogate and sign a surrogacy agreement with independent attorneys on both sides; 5) complete the surrogate's medical cycle and frozen embryo transfer, with a pregnancy test 9 to 11 days later; 6) obtain a pre-birth parentage order naming both fathers, then attend the birth. The whole sequence typically takes 18 to 24 months.

Portrait of Nancy Block, RN, founder and director of Private Label Surrogacy

Written by Nancy Block, RN

Founder and Director. Fertility nurse, 17 years at Northwestern Memorial Hospital. Former Co-President of SEEDS.

Medically reviewed by Mark Silverberg, DDS, MD, October 2026

Last updated

Two fathers smiling at their baby on a bed

What has to happen before you can match with a surrogate?

Two things: you sign with an agency, and you have a plan for embryos. Surrogacy for two dads runs in six steps, and the first two set up everything after them.

Step What happens Typical duration Who is responsible
1. Sign and set up escrow Consultation, PLS agreement, independent escrow arranged A few weeks Parents, PLS, escrow agent
2. Egg donor and testing Donor match; sperm testing and FDA-required infectious disease screening Her cycle comes first and adds about 3 to 6 months Parents, clinic
3. Embryo creation IVF with the donor's eggs; chromosome testing if you choose it; freezing One or more IVF cycles, set by the clinic Clinic, parents
4. Surrogate match and agreement Introduction, mutual acceptance, independent attorneys, signed agreement Matched about nine months after signing on average; four to six weeks for the legal phase PLS, attorneys, escrow agent
5. Transfer cycle and pregnancy Surrogate's medications, frozen embryo transfer, pregnancy test 9 to 11 days later 2 to 3 months, then the pregnancy Clinic, surrogate, PLS
6. Parentage and birth Pre-birth parentage order naming both fathers; birth plan; delivery During the pregnancy and at birth Attorneys, hospital, PLS
Whole journey 18 to 24 months

Most journeys run closer to 24 months from start through delivery.

Step 1: Sign and set up escrow. Your first meeting is about an hour by video with Nancy Block, RN, who founded Private Label Surrogacy in 2017, often with Mark. You talk through your family plan, your clinic, your budget and your timeline. When you sign, you also arrange an independent licensed escrow account. PLS never holds your money. Escrow generally opens after medical clearance. Costs that come before that are invoiced to the intended parents directly, not through escrow. PLS refers you to two licensed independent escrow companies once you sign with us, and you may choose your own.

Step 2: Egg donor and testing. You choose an egg donor, and both of you complete sperm testing and the FDA-required infectious disease screening at your clinic.

In most journeys the egg donor cycle comes first: her eggs are retrieved, embryos are created and usually frozen, often after chromosome testing, and the transfer to your surrogate follows.

How are the embryos created, and who provides the sperm?

Your clinic stimulates the egg donor's ovaries, retrieves her eggs and fertilizes them by IVF. The embryos grow for several days to the blastocyst stage. Many IVF patients choose PGT-A, a chromosome test of a few cells from each blastocyst, before freezing; whether to test is a decision between you and your doctor. Frozen embryos are what the surrogate's transfer cycle will use.

Each embryo has one genetic father. You choose how to divide that:

  • One father provides sperm for all embryos. The simplest plan, and often the choice when a couple expects to use the other father's sperm for a second child.
  • Split the eggs. Half the donor's eggs are fertilized with each partner's sperm. You end up with embryos from both fathers in storage, and siblings who share the same egg donor.

Known or anonymous donor? Either works. Many two-dad couples choose a relative of the non-genetic father, such as his sister, so the child is related to both fathers. A known donor completes FDA screening, a psychological consult and has her own attorney. For help with the sperm decision, see whose sperm to use.

How does matching with a surrogate work for gay couples?

On average, intended parents are matched about nine months after signing. It depends on the clinic's criteria and on what you are looking for in a surrogate. Matching timelines vary with the fertility clinic's criteria and with what intended parents and surrogates are looking for.

Nancy is involved in every match and oversees it. Your case manager manages the day-to-day journey. Nancy has worked in egg donation and surrogacy matching since 2000. Before you meet anyone, three things have already happened:

  1. The surrogate has said yes to two dads. Every PLS surrogate is asked at intake whether she is open to same-sex couples. You are introduced only to surrogates who have said yes.
  2. A doctor has reviewed her available records. Mark Silverberg, DDS, MD, reviews the surrogate's available medical records before she is presented to you. His summary is confidential: only PLS and your clinic receive it.
  3. She has been screened. Application, interview, background check, insurance review and a psychological evaluation by an independent licensed professional. Your clinic then completes her medical screening.

You talk with the surrogate, and both sides decide. If either side says no, Nancy keeps looking. If both say yes, you are matched and the legal work begins.

The main document is the gestational carrier agreement, signed by both fathers and the surrogate. It sets out:

  • Her compensation, allowances and expenses
  • Health insurance and life insurance
  • How medical decisions are made during the pregnancy
  • How many embryos may be transferred, usually one
  • What happens if a transfer fails or a pregnancy is lost
  • How the escrow account pays out

Each side has its own attorney. PLS does not employ attorneys and refers you to independent reproductive-law attorneys. You pay for both attorneys. Illinois law, as amended by the Equality for Every Family Act in December 2025, requires independent counsel for both sides.

You also sign the escrow agreement with your escrow agent. If you use a known egg donor, she signs a separate donor agreement with her own attorney.

Does the surrogate choose which embryo is transferred? No. Embryo selection is between you and your clinic. The surrogate agrees, in the agreement, to the number of embryos transferred.

Nothing medical starts until the agreement is signed.

What happens during the transfer cycle and pregnancy?

The surrogate's medical cycle takes 2 to 3 months. She takes medications to prepare her uterus, does monitoring bloodwork and ultrasounds at a clinic near home, then travels to your clinic for the frozen embryo transfer. You can attend if your clinic allows it. The pregnancy test is 9 to 11 days after transfer.

If the test is positive, your clinic follows the early pregnancy until it releases her to her own obstetric care. Through the pregnancy:

  • Her case manager, Natalie Gaudio-Fricano or Jenni Symons, both former surrogates, stays in regular contact with her and with you.
  • Escrow pays her according to the agreement, from the escrow account.

How much contact you have with your surrogate is agreed at match, so both sides know what to expect.

How does birth and parentage work for both fathers?

In Illinois, your attorneys file the paperwork for pre-birth parentage during the pregnancy, so that both fathers are named as legal parents and on the original birth certificate. Since the Equality for Every Family Act, the non-genetic father's parentage under Illinois law does not depend on a genetic link.

Many attorneys also recommend a confirmatory adoption or judgment for the non-genetic father, because a court judgment is honored in every state and abroad. Your attorney advises on that.

PLS coordinates a birth plan with the delivering hospital before labor begins. It names you as the parents and covers who is in the delivery room, who holds the baby first and how discharge will work. Who attends the birth is agreed between you and the surrogate; most PLS surrogates welcome both fathers.

What does PLS do at each step?

Step What PLS does
1. Sign and set up escrow Nancy's consultation and plan; referral to independent escrow agents
2. Egg donor Your clinic and your egg donor program or egg bank lead this step
3. Embryos Coordination with your clinic so embryos are ready before transfer
4. Match Surrogate screening, Dr. Silverberg's review of the surrogate's available records, Nancy's involvement in the match, attorney referrals
5. Transfer and pregnancy Case management, travel coordination, escrow oversight
6. Birth Birth plan with the hospital; coordination with both attorneys

What PLS does not do is hold your money, employ your attorney or employ the psychologist who evaluates your surrogate. Those stay independent on purpose, so each professional answers to the person they serve.

For the bigger picture, including cost and legal options, see gay surrogacy and LGBTQ+ family building. For how escrow protects you, see escrow.

Sources

  • Illinois Gestational Surrogacy Act (2005), Illinois General Assembly.
  • Equality for Every Family Act, signed December 2025, Illinois General Assembly.
  • US Food and Drug Administration, donor eligibility and infectious disease screening requirements.
Questions people ask

Frequently asked questions

Do we create embryos before or after matching with a surrogate?

Usually before. In most journeys the egg donor cycle comes first: embryos are created and usually frozen, often after chromosome testing, and the transfer to your surrogate follows.

Can we use a known egg donor, such as a sister of one partner?

Yes, subject to FDA screening, a psychological consult and separate legal counsel for the donor. Many two-dad couples use a relative of the non-genetic father.

Does the surrogate have any say in which embryo is transferred?

No. Embryo selection is a decision between the parents and the clinic. The surrogate agrees to the number of embryos transferred (usually one) in the surrogacy agreement.

Who is in the delivery room?

Whoever the surrogate and parents agree on in the birth plan. Most PLS surrogates welcome both fathers at the birth.

Read next