Which parts of surrogacy are regulated, and by whom?
Most parts of a surrogacy journey are regulated. The agency, in most states, is the exception.
Each professional you work with answers to a different authority:
- The surrogacy agreement is governed by state law. In Illinois, that is the Illinois Gestational Surrogacy Act of 2005.
- Fertility clinics follow FDA rules on screening and testing for donated eggs, sperm and embryos, and professional standards from ASRM. Clinics report their IVF outcomes to the CDC, and many are members of SART, which publishes clinic data.
- Doctors and nurses are licensed by state boards.
- Attorneys are licensed by the state bar where they practice.
- Escrow agents are licensed under the rules that apply to them in their state.
- Psychologists and other mental-health professionals are licensed by state boards.
| Actor | Regulator | What it covers | How to verify |
|---|---|---|---|
| Surrogacy agency | In most states, no state licensing; New York licenses surrogacy programs | Recruitment, matching, coordination | Ask for its escrow arrangements, its standards and any state license |
| Fertility clinic | FDA; ASRM professional standards; CDC reporting | Donor screening and testing; medical practice; outcome reporting | CDC and SART clinic data; clinic accreditation |
| Doctors and nurses | State medical and nursing boards | Professional license | State license lookup |
| Attorney | State bar | License to practice law | State bar lookup |
| Escrow agent | State licensing, which varies by state | Holding and disbursing client funds | Ask for its license and check it with the issuing state |
| Psychologist | State licensing board | Professional license | State license lookup |
Why are agencies themselves mostly unregulated?
Because state surrogacy laws were written around the agreement and parentage, not around the businesses that arrange them.
When states made gestational surrogacy agreements enforceable, the focus was on who the legal parents are, what the agreement must contain and when it must be signed. The Illinois Gestational Surrogacy Act governs the agreement and parentage; there is no Illinois state license for surrogacy agencies.
The result is a gap. In most states, no license is needed to open a surrogacy agency, and no state agency checks how it screens surrogates, handles money or advertises.
PLS does not hold funds for surrogate expenses or surrogate compensation. An independent licensed escrow company does.
Which states license surrogacy agencies?
New York is the main example. New York's Child-Parent Security Act, in effect since 2021, requires surrogacy programs to be licensed by the state.
Michigan legalized compensated surrogacy in April 2025. Laws in this area are changing quickly. Check the current status in the states where you and your surrogate live.
What does New York's licensing require?
Private Label Surrogacy (PLS) is applying for a New York license.
What substitutes for regulation: escrow, ASRM guidance, counsel
Where the agency is not regulated, three things do the protective work.
Independent licensed escrow. Your money is held by a licensed escrow agent that answers to you, not by the agency. PLS has always used independent licensed escrow. Escrow generally opens after medical clearance. Costs that come before that are invoiced to the intended parents directly, not through escrow. PLS refers you to independent attorneys, escrow companies, insurance agencies (including surrogate-friendly policies) and fertility clinics when you need them. You choose which providers to use. See how escrow works.
Professional guidance. ASRM, the American Society for Reproductive Medicine, publishes guidance on gestational carriers. It is not a regulator, but it gives you something in writing to measure an agency against. PLS follows ASRM guidance, and PLS founder Nancy Block, RN, is a former Co-President of SEEDS. See what this means.
Written contracts with independent counsel. Each side has its own attorney, who answers only to that client. The gestational carrier agreement sets out every payment, every responsibility and what happens if something goes wrong. See surrogacy legal contracts.
How to check an agency's standing in your state
- Ask whether your state licenses surrogacy agencies. In most states the answer is no. If you or your surrogate live in New York, ask to see the license or its application status.
- Ask for the escrow company's name and license. Then check the license yourself.
- Ask about standards. Does the agency publish a written standard? Will it show you how it meets each part?
- Check for complaints. Search the agency's name with the words lawsuit, complaint and indictment. Check your state attorney general's consumer protection office.
- Ask who the agency employs. Agencies that employ the attorneys or psychologists they refer you to have a conflict of interest.
For warning signs about money, see agency financial red flags.
What is PLS's regulatory status?
PLS is a gestational surrogacy agency based in Northbrook, Illinois. Illinois does not license surrogacy agencies. Its journeys are built around the Illinois Gestational Surrogacy Act and the laws of each surrogate's home state.
In place of agency regulation, PLS holds itself to standards you can check: independent licensed escrow, independent attorneys and psychologists, a doctor's review of the surrogate's available medical records, and a founder who is a former Co-President of SEEDS. PLS does not employ in-house psychologists, attorneys or escrow.
Sources
- Illinois Gestational Surrogacy Act (2005).
- New York Child-Parent Security Act.
- ASRM (American Society for Reproductive Medicine). https://www.asrm.org
- SART (Society for Assisted Reproductive Technology). https://www.sart.org
- CDC (Centers for Disease Control and Prevention), assisted reproductive technology reporting. https://www.cdc.gov