Private Label Surrogacy
Menu
Choosing an agency

Independent surrogacy agency or national agency: which is right for you?

The short answer

An independent surrogacy agency is run locally, with a named senior person involved in matching; a national agency runs hundreds of journeys a year with departmental teams and a larger surrogate pool. The trade-off is reach versus attention: national agencies offer more profiles and more locations; independent agencies offer a personal, responsive approach and direct access to decision-makers. At Private Label Surrogacy, an independent agency, Nancy is involved in every match and oversees it. Your case manager manages the day-to-day journey. The escrow and screening standards should be the same at any size.

Portrait of Nancy Block, RN, founder and director of Private Label Surrogacy

Written by Nancy Block, RN

Founder and Director. Fertility nurse, 17 years at Northwestern Memorial Hospital. Former Co-President of SEEDS.

Last updated

Woman in an apron arranging tulips in a small shop window

What defines an independent agency?

An independent surrogacy agency is a locally run agency with three features:

  1. A named senior person is involved in matching. Often the founder. You know who is overseeing your criteria and the surrogate presented to you.
  2. Consistent case managers. You can ask who your case manager will be before you sign.
  3. One team, not departments. The person who did your intake still knows your file at delivery.

A national agency runs hundreds of journeys a year. It is organized by department: intake, matching, case management, finance, often in different offices. It has a larger pool of surrogates and may recruit across more states.

Neither model is better for every family. The choice is a trade-off between reach and attention. This page sets out what each does well, where the difference matters and where it does not, so you can decide which fits you.

Independent agency National agency
Who matches you A named senior person, often the founder A matching department or coordinator
Case manager continuity Usually one case manager from match to birth Can change as staff and departments change
Surrogate pool size Smaller Larger
Locations Fewer surrogacy-friendly states More states, sometimes more offices
After-hours access A team that knows your file Varies; ask who answers and whether they know your file
Pricing Fees overlap with national agencies Fees overlap with independent agencies
Escalation path One or two steps to a senior decision-maker Several layers to a decision-maker

What do national agencies do better?

Reach. National agencies have advantages that come from scale, and they are worth naming plainly.

  • A larger surrogate pool. More screened surrogates at any time means more possible matches for specific criteria, such as a particular state or a narrow window.
  • More locations. Some recruit across many states and have staff in several regions.
  • Depth in departments. A large agency may have dedicated staff for insurance, travel or international documents.
  • Volume experience. An agency running hundreds of journeys a year has seen many unusual situations.

If your criteria are narrow, or you need a surrogate in one specific state, a larger pool can help.

What do independent agencies do better?

Attention. The advantages come from a team that knows each family.

  • Direct access to decision-makers. You can reach senior people involved in your match, and they can make a decision.
  • Consistency. One case manager manages your journey and knows your surrogate.
  • Faster escalation. When something goes wrong, the team that answers knows your file.
  • Surrogates treated as partners. The team gets to know each surrogate: her preferences, her family and her goals.

Independent is not automatically cheaper. Fees overlap. The difference is in the kind of attention you get.

Does agency type affect wait time?

Sometimes, in both directions.

A larger pool can mean more profiles to choose from. It does not mean a faster match, because a national agency also has more families waiting. An independent agency may have a smaller pool and fewer families. If your criteria are flexible, the wait can be similar.

On average, intended parents are matched about nine months after signing. It depends on the clinic's criteria and on what you are looking for in a surrogate. Matching timelines vary with the fertility clinic's criteria and with what intended parents and surrogates are looking for. The whole journey typically runs 18 to 24 months. Most journeys run closer to 24 months from start through delivery.

Ask every agency the same question: how long from signing to introduction, measured over the past year? Compare like with like. See surrogacy agency wait times.

Does agency type affect safety?

Not in the way you might expect. What protects families is where the money is held, not how big the agency is.

PLS does not hold funds for surrogate expenses or surrogate compensation. An independent licensed escrow company does. The question is who holds the money, and whom they answer to.

Agency size is not what protects you. What does protect you, at any size:

  • Independent licensed escrow. Your money is held by a licensed escrow agent, not by the agency. PLS refers you to independent attorneys, escrow companies, insurance agencies (including surrogate-friendly policies) and fertility clinics when you need them. You choose which providers to use.
  • Independent professionals. Attorneys, psychologists and escrow agents who answer to their own clients, not to the agency.
  • Written, published standards you can read and hold the agency to.

PLS has always used independent licensed escrow. It has taken on three pro bono cases from another agency. See how escrow works.

The escrow and screening standards should be the same at any size. If an agency of any size cannot show you independent escrow, keep looking.

How does PLS operate as an independent agency?

PLS is an independent agency in Northbrook, Illinois, serving intended parents across the US and abroad.

  • Matching. Nancy Block, RN, the founder, is involved in every match and oversees it. She has made more than 4,000 matches since 2000. See how matching works.
  • Case management. Your case manager manages the day-to-day journey. PLS case managers Natalie Gaudio-Fricano and Jenni Symons have both carried as gestational surrogates themselves.
  • Medical review. Mark Silverberg, DDS, MD, Executive Director, reviews the surrogate's available medical records, summarizes them and flags inconsistencies before she is presented to you. All available records go to your fertility clinic. His summary is confidential: only PLS and your clinic receive it.
  • Coordination. Jan Telman Berman, Global Surrogacy Coordinator, manages national and international cycles. Jo Ann Levitan, Director of Operations, runs operations.
  • A personal, responsive approach: you know who is looking after your journey, and we answer quickly.
  • After hours. Your case manager is reachable after hours when needed. This is not a line staffed 24 hours a day; in an emergency call 911, and for a mental health crisis call or text 988.

PLS does not employ in-house psychologists, attorneys or escrow. It refers to independent licensed professionals on purpose, to avoid conflicts of interest.

The trade-off applies here too. A national agency may offer a larger surrogate pool. What you get at PLS in exchange is Nancy's involvement in every match and a case manager who has been a surrogate herself. See why a nurse-led agency matters.

Questions that expose the difference in a consultation

Ask these of any agency, national or independent. The answers tell you more than the website.

  1. Who will match us, by name? And how many matches has that person made?
  2. Who will be our case manager, and how do we reach her?
  3. Will the same case manager stay with us from match to birth?
  4. Who answers the phone at night or on a weekend?
  5. Where is our money held? Ask for the escrow company's name and license.
  6. Who reviews the surrogate's medical records? A coordinator, a nurse or a doctor?
  7. Do you employ the attorneys or psychologists you refer us to? Do you take referral fees?
  8. How long from signing to introduction, measured over the past year?
  9. If something goes wrong, how many steps is it to a senior decision-maker?

For a fuller list, see how to choose a surrogacy agency.

Sources

  • ASRM (American Society for Reproductive Medicine), guidance on gestational carriers. https://www.asrm.org
Questions people ask

Frequently asked questions

Do independent agencies take longer to match?

Sometimes, because the pool can be smaller. On average, intended parents are matched about nine months after signing. It depends on the clinic's criteria and on what you are looking for in a surrogate.

Are independent agencies cheaper?

Not necessarily. Fees overlap; the difference is in the kind of attention you get.

Who is involved in matching at PLS?

Nancy Block, RN, the founder, is involved in every match and oversees it, with more than 4,000 matches since she founded her first agency in 2000. Your case manager manages the day-to-day journey.

Is an independent agency riskier if it closes?

Not when funds are in independent escrow; agency size did not protect clients in recent agency failures.

Read next