Private Label Surrogacy
Menu
LGBTQ+ and single parents

How do gay dads choose an egg donor?

The short answer

Gay dads choose an egg donor on ten criteria: age (usually 21 to 30), BMI (healthy, with height and weight in proportion), personal health history, family health history, proven fertility, genetic carrier screening matched to the sperm provider's panel, psychological evaluation, physical traits, personal traits, and compensation (agreed per match). Two decisions are specific to two dads: whether to pick a donor who resembles the non-genetic father, and whether to choose a known donor such as a relative of the non-genetic partner, so both families are represented genetically. PLS was founded by the nurse who ran The Center for Egg Options for 15 years.

Portrait of Nancy Block, RN, founder and director of Private Label Surrogacy

Written by Nancy Block, RN

Founder and Director. Fertility nurse, 17 years at Northwestern Memorial Hospital. Former Co-President of SEEDS.

Medically reviewed by Mark Silverberg, DDS, MD, October 2026

Last updated

Two men on a porch swing sharing a notebook with tulips in the yard

Where do gay couples find egg donors?

Two dads find egg donors in the same four places as any intended parent. What changes is which source fits your plan for whose sperm to use.

  • Egg donor agencies. The largest pools, with the most choice on ancestry, height, education and other traits. A first-time donor may have little screening done before her profile goes live, so ask what is complete.
  • Fertility clinic donor programs. Smaller, more local pools, usually pre-screened before listing.
  • Known donors. A relative or friend donates for you. For two dads, this is often a sister or cousin of the partner who will not provide sperm.
  • Frozen egg banks. You buy a set number of frozen eggs from a donor who has already cycled. Faster, but you get a fixed lot, not her whole cycle.

Donors state at intake which family types they are open to.

What are the ten criteria to weigh?

The same ten criteria apply to every family. The first seven affect the chance of a healthy embryo and a healthy child. The last three are personal. This table adds what each one means for two dads.

# Criterion Typical range or standard Why it matters for two dads
1 Age Usually 21 to 30 Younger eggs mean more normal embryos to divide between two fathers
2 BMI Healthy, height and weight in proportion (typically BMI 18 to 27) Affects how she responds to stimulation, and so how many eggs you have to split
3 Personal health history Non-smoker, no illegal drug use, appropriate FDA questionnaire answers Same standard for every family
4 Family health history No major hereditary conditions in her or her first and second degree relatives She is the only genetic mother your children will have
5 Proven fertility A prior healthy pregnancy or prior donor cycle results; preferred, not required A proven egg yield helps you plan whether a split cycle will give both fathers enough embryos
6 Genetic carrier screening Same or a similar panel as the sperm provider In a split cycle, her report is compared with both fathers' reports, not one
7 Psychological evaluation Understands what donation involves and its long-term meaning Same standard for every family
8 Physical characteristics Height, weight, hair and eye color Some couples look for a resemblance to the non-genetic father
9 Personal traits Ethnicity, education, interests Some couples look for the non-genetic father's ancestry
10 Compensation Agreed per match; higher for proven donors and donors whose background is less common Same for any family; known donors may waive it

If a donor fails on one of the first seven, keep looking, however close she is on the last three.

Should the donor resemble the non-genetic dad?

That is your choice. Medical and genetic criteria affect the outcome. Appearance does not.

Some two-dad couples choose a donor who shares the non-genetic father's coloring, height or ancestry, so a child may look like both of you. Others do not weigh resemblance at all.

Two suggestions:

  • Agree on your top three traits before you browse. It keeps you from passing over a strong medical match for a detail neither of you would miss later.
  • Think about the long term. If you choose an identity-release or known donor, your child may meet her one day. Her values and personality may matter more to you then than her hair color.

If you plan a split cycle, the same donor serves both fathers. Your children will share a genetic mother, which many two-dad families value.

Should we use a relative of one partner as a known donor?

It is a common choice for two dads. If the sister or cousin of one partner donates eggs and the other partner provides sperm, both families are represented genetically in your child.

It works when everyone goes in with clear expectations. A known donor still needs:

  • FDA screening, including infectious disease testing close to the retrieval.
  • A psychological consult for her, and counseling for you, about roles in your child's life, what your child will be told, and how family events will feel.
  • Her own independent attorney and a written donor agreement.
  • Genetic carrier screening matched to the father providing sperm. A relative of one partner is not related to the other, so this is the usual carrier comparison.

Compensation is optional for a known donor. The clinic, legal and screening costs still apply.

Your relative's age matters as much as any other donor's. Many clinics set an upper age limit for known donors. Ask your clinic early.

Fresh, frozen or bank eggs: what works best for a split cycle?

A split cycle divides one donor's eggs between both fathers. The more eggs you start with, the more embryos each father ends up with. That makes the source of eggs a bigger decision for two dads than for most couples.

Fresh agency or clinic cycle. The donor goes through stimulation for you, and you receive all the eggs from her retrieval. A fresh cycle usually gives more eggs, which suits a split cycle best.

Frozen bank eggs. Faster and cheaper per batch, but a bank lot is a fixed number of eggs, and thawed eggs yield fewer embryos. Divided between two fathers, a single lot may leave each with only one or two embryos. Some couples buy two lots, or use bank eggs for one father only.

If you want two or more children from each father, ask your clinic how many eggs it expects from your donor, and whether a second retrieval might be needed. For the options on whose sperm to use, see whose sperm is used in gay surrogacy.

What screening must be complete before retrieval?

Before the donor starts stimulation medications, her file should show:

  • FDA donor eligibility screening. Her questionnaire and infectious disease test results, timed close to the retrieval. A result from a past cycle does not cover yours.
  • Genetic carrier screening, compared with both fathers' reports if you plan a split cycle, and reviewed by a genetic counselor.
  • The clinic's medical screen. Exam, bloodwork and ultrasound, which suggest how her ovaries will respond.
  • A psychological evaluation by a licensed mental health professional.
  • A signed donor agreement, with an independent attorney for her and one for you.

Both fathers complete their own semen analysis, infectious disease testing and carrier screening before the retrieval too.

Sources

  • American Society for Reproductive Medicine (ASRM), guidance on gamete donor screening.
  • US Food and Drug Administration (FDA), donor eligibility rules (21 CFR Part 1271).
  • Private Label Surrogacy, "Advice from PLS: 10 Considerations When Choosing Your Egg Donor."
Questions people ask

Frequently asked questions

Can a sister of one partner donate eggs for the other partner's sperm?

Yes. It is a common choice for two dads. FDA screening, a psychological consult and independent counsel for the donor are still required.

Should we pick a donor from a bank or an agency?

Frozen bank eggs are faster and cheaper per batch but yield fewer embryos; a fresh agency cycle gives more eggs for a split cycle.

Do egg donors know the recipients are a gay couple?

Donors state at intake which family types they are open to.

Read next