Is surrogacy legal in New York?
Yes. Compensated gestational surrogacy has been legal in New York since February 15, 2021, under the Child-Parent Security Act.
The Act did three things that matter for families. It created a Surrogates' Bill of Rights. It requires surrogacy agencies operating in New York to be licensed by the state. And it lets intended parents obtain a pre-birth parentage order.
Private Label Surrogacy is preparing its New York program license application. Until PLS is licensed, it does not match New York residents; New York surrogates may join a waitlist.
This page is written by Jan Telman Berman, Global Surrogacy Coordinator at PLS, who manages national and international cycles. It is not legal advice. Your own New York reproductive attorney advises you before you sign.
| New York at a glance | |
|---|---|
| Legal basis | Child-Parent Security Act, in force February 15, 2021 |
| Status | Legal by statute since 2021; agencies must be licensed; PLS is preparing its license application |
| Parentage method | Pre-birth parentage order under the Child-Parent Security Act |
| Who can be an intended parent | At least one intended parent or the surrogate must have lived in New York for six months |
| Surrogate requirements | At least 21; US citizen or permanent resident; protected by the Surrogates' Bill of Rights |
| Compensation permitted | Yes, since February 15, 2021 |
| PLS accepts surrogates here | License application in preparation; PLS does not match New York residents until licensed, and New York surrogates may join a waitlist |
What law governs surrogacy in New York?
The Child-Parent Security Act governs surrogacy in New York. It took effect on February 15, 2021, and made compensated gestational surrogacy agreements legal and enforceable.
The Act's Surrogates' Bill of Rights gives the surrogate:
- Independent legal counsel of her choosing, paid for by the intended parents.
- Health insurance.
- The right to make her own medical decisions during the pregnancy.
- Life insurance.
The Act also requires surrogacy agencies that operate in New York to hold a state program license.
Most of those protections are already standard on a PLS journey in every state. Every PLS surrogate has her own attorney, paid by the intended parents. Her health plan is reviewed before match, and the intended parents buy a dedicated policy if her plan excludes surrogacy. We recommend a term life policy of $750,000 for every PLS surrogate's journey; the attorneys set the exact terms in the Direct Agreement.
Confirm the current statutory requirements with New York counsel before signing.
How is parentage established in New York: pre-birth or post-birth?
Pre-birth. Under the Child-Parent Security Act, intended parents can obtain a parentage order before the baby is born. The order names the intended parents, and the hospital uses it so they are recorded as the parents from birth.
In practice:
- The agreement is signed before any medication, with each side represented by its own attorney.
- Your attorney files for the order during the pregnancy, so it is ready well before the due date.
- The delivering hospital receives the order and a birth plan before labor begins, so staff know who the parents are and how discharge will work.
For a comparison with states that settle parentage after delivery, see pre-birth vs post-birth parentage orders.
Who can be an intended parent in New York?
The Child-Parent Security Act includes a residency rule: at least one intended parent or the surrogate must have lived in New York for six months.
Confirm with New York counsel how the Act treats marital status, single intended parents and genetic connection.
PLS treats single parents, same-sex couples and every other intended parent the same way, with the same process and standard of care. A New York attorney will confirm the legal path for your family.
If you live in New York and want to start now, you can match with a surrogate in a state where PLS is already active. Confirm with New York counsel what PLS may do for New York residents before it is licensed. In Illinois, PLS's home state, the Gestational Surrogacy Act provides pre-birth parentage.
Who can be a surrogate in New York?
Under the Child-Parent Security Act, a surrogate must be at least 21 and a US citizen or permanent resident. PLS's own criteria sit on top of that. To apply with PLS, a surrogate must be:
- 21 to 43 years old
- A US citizen or permanent resident
- Within the BMI limit set by the clinic (each clinic sets its own)
- Someone who has had at least one healthy full-term pregnancy and is raising a child now
- A non-smoker
- Financially stable, and not relying on government assistance
- Living in a stable home
- Not currently taking antidepressant or anti-anxiety medication (a treated, resolved history is reviewed case by case with the clinic)
Screening has seven steps: application, interview, a records review by Mark Silverberg, DDS, MD, a background check, an insurance review, a psychological evaluation by an independent licensed professional, and medical clearance by the surrogate's physician or OB. Dr. Silverberg reviews the surrogate's available medical records, summarizes them and flags inconsistencies. All available records go to your fertility clinic. His summary is confidential: only PLS and your clinic receive it.
New York surrogates may join the PLS New York waitlist now; matching begins once PLS is licensed.
How does PLS work with New York surrogates and parents?
PLS is preparing its application for the New York program license required by the Child-Parent Security Act. Until PLS is licensed, it does not match New York residents. Once licensed, the New York journey will follow the same sequence as every PLS journey:
- Consultation and signing. Your first meeting is about an hour by video with Nancy, often with Mark. Nancy Block, RN, founded PLS in 2017. Nancy is involved in every match and oversees it. Your case manager manages the day-to-day journey.
- Matching. On average, intended parents are matched about nine months after signing. It depends on the clinic's criteria and on what you are looking for in a surrogate. Matching timelines vary with the fertility clinic's criteria and with what intended parents and surrogates are looking for.
- Legal phase (agreements signed), usually four to six weeks. Each side retains its own attorney.
- Medical cycle, 2 to 3 months, ending in the embryo transfer at your clinic, with a pregnancy test 9 to 11 days later.
- Pregnancy, with the pre-birth order filed by your attorney.
- Birth, with the hospital already holding the order and the birth plan.
The whole journey typically takes 18 to 24 months. Most journeys run closer to 24 months from start through delivery.
Each surrogate's PLS case manager, Natalie Gaudio-Fricano or Jenni Symons, both former surrogates, stays with her through delivery.
PLS does not employ attorneys, psychologists or escrow staff. PLS refers you to independent attorneys, escrow companies, insurance agencies (including surrogate-friendly policies) and fertility clinics when you need them. You choose which providers to use. That stance lines up with the Act's requirement of independent counsel for the surrogate.
What does a New York journey cost and how is money held?
PLS fees and surrogate compensation are the same in every PLS state. Intended parents typically budget $150,000 to $210,000 with clinic fees and insurance; clinic charges are separate and vary widely from clinic to clinic. The main parts are:
- PLS program fee. $47,500*. It is paid in three payments: first payment when you sign the agreement, $22,500*; second payment at matching, $20,000*; third payment at medical clearance by the fertility center, $5,000*.
- Surrogate compensation. A typical total package of roughly $68,000 to $78,000*, built on $60,000* first-time base compensation (up from $55,000), or, for an experienced surrogate, usually from $65,000* for a second journey and $70,000* for a third or later, with no cap. See surrogate compensation in New York.
- Third-party costs, $15,300 to $29,000: attorneys on both sides, escrow, the psychological evaluation, background check, insurance review, travel and local monitoring.
- Surrogate health insurance, $5,000 to $40,000, only if her plan excludes surrogacy.
- IVF and clinic fees, paid directly to your clinic.
These costs are estimates and may vary. Only PLS program fees are fixed.
Money is held by an independent licensed escrow agent, never by PLS. Escrow generally opens after medical clearance. Costs that come before that are invoiced to the intended parents directly, not through escrow. You may choose your own escrow company. PLS does not hold funds for surrogate expenses or surrogate compensation. An independent licensed escrow company does. PLS has used independent licensed escrow since 2017.
See the cost of surrogacy for the itemized budget and surrogacy laws by state to compare New York with other states.
Sources
- Child-Parent Security Act (in force February 15, 2021), New York State Legislature.
- New York State surrogacy program licensing requirements.
- Illinois Gestational Surrogacy Act (2005), Illinois General Assembly.